One reason why I hate beans.

I’m now poking around some source code for a project that was built with a bunch of little beans. I understand the theory of a Java bean: by segregating your code into small and self-contained modules it makes development easier (the person developing the bean should only worry about just that bean), and it makes debugging easier (you can host the bean in a test framework and test it in isolation).

However (and there is always a ‘however’ in my rants), I’m reminded of a post on Cocoa development: Thoughts about large Cocoa projects:

My app isn’t huge compared to Photoshop or Word—it’s teeny in comparison—but it’s large compared to some Cocoa apps. (It has 345 .m files and an executable size of 3.2MB when stripped.)

It’s big enough that, were you to ask me how _____ works, I’d have to go look. There’s no way I can remember, with any level of detail, how every part of it works.

I call it the Research Barrier, when an app is big enough that the developer sometimes has to do research to figure things out. (“Research” just means reading the code and following some paths of execution, sometimes running in the debugger.)

To summarize my problem with beans and the Spring framework and other systems which are designed to encapsulate your Java program into a bunch of small objects interconnected with a mechanism that uses Java reflection to hook things together is that it breaks the “research barrier.” It makes answering the question “who calls this?” and “what does it call?” much harder–if not impossible–to answer. Rather than making the answer ‘who calls this’ a matter of right-clicking on the method call in Eclipse and doing a search, you cannot answer the question anymore in a reasonable way: the entire application has been reduced to a complex dance of dozens or hundreds of jar files. Worse: the overall ‘flow’ of the application is no long encapsulated in a handful of classes but instead lives in some configuration file which–by design–can change without notice.

So here I am with a bunch of beans and all I want to answer is “what database tables are queried to generate a report?” The answer? With all these beans scattered around, apparently the answer changes with the phase of the moon.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s